Whether small, medium or large – I’ve had the honor over the past several years of being a part of so many truly special people’s lives through an occasion that meant everything to them. Need a reference? Let me know!

Engagement parties, baby showers, wedding showers, Staff appreciation (from small family owned businesses to large corporations), nursing, assisted and dementia care staff thank you’s, graduation parties, teacher gifts, shower gifts, host and hostess gifts, housewarming gifts, open house parties, wedding table gifts, wedding dessert tables….the list is endless!


Summer is just around the corner ….. with me the dessert table will be a HUGE HIT! Whether you are celebrating a graduate, an engagement, an anniversary, a baby, a Holiday or just gathering with family or friends …call on me to eliminate stress from your planning.

Last summer I was known to go “off menu” and, in addition to my cookies, scones, biscotti & bundts, I provided customers with an entire dessert buffet, customized to their pallette. I am happy to do the same for you.


Naturally gluten free, these flourless peanut butter cookies make the perfect anytime snack. If you’re a peanut butter lover, you definitely need these soft, rich chewy cookies in your life. They will satisfy any sweet tooth and have a life span of about five minutes! Plain, with semi sweet chocolate chunks or dipped!

$25 per bakers dozen dipped

$20 per bakers dozen with chocolate chunks

$18 per bakers dozen plain


Every time I have expanded my menu it has been due to my amazing customers’ requests.  I cannot say enough how successful these suggestions have been – blueberry, lemon & pumpkin scones, followed by a mini version of said scones; coffee cake followed by a mini version of said coffee cake, also known as mini bundts; and, most recently, gluten free cinnamon chip and pumpkin scones, followed by gluten free oversized peanut butter cookies. Well, I guess I am not done with my expansion.  The latest request has been for Christmas Cookies!

Discover fresh baked cookies this season from Broken Tastes the Same. A festively boxed bakers dozen in which you will find:

Chewy Butterscotch…soft, chewy and bursting with butterscotch flavor these cookies are topped with melted white chocolate which makes the perfect butterscotch complement.

Lemon Glazed Shortbread….. You’ll love the fresh burst of lemon flavor in these buttery tender shortbread cookies. And, if that’s not enough to tempt your taste buds, they get dipped in a tart, lemony glaze. These are seriously addicting.

Snickerdoodle Sandwich…your classic snickerdoodle, rolled in cinnamon and sugar, but sandwiched between white chocolate frosting.  Ordinary snickerdoodles won’t cut it once you’ve tried these.

Peanut Butter Dipped…. a crisp crunch with a smooth peanut butter flavor when you bite in followed by the magnificent combination of semi-sweet chocolate. These will have a life span of about five minutes!

Priced at $15.00


Did you know I do events? Let me ease your stress and handle everything you may need from conception through delivery. My gifts are unique, delicious and certainly memorable. Encompassing but certainly not limited to:

*Bridesmaid/Maid of Honor Gifts

*Bridal Shower

*Wedding Shower

*Wedding Welcome Bags

*Wedding Favors

*Baby Shower

*Holiday Brunches

*Graduation Parties


Contact me for your personalized package!!


For those of you who may not have read “My Story” on this website or on my Facebook Page, I wanted to share an excerpt from it…..

My goal for Broken Tastes the Same is to continue to grow to the point that with every order I receive I would be able to provide each customer with a “pay it forward” goodie that they could give to someone they know who is having a hard day, struggling with loss or who just needs to know someone is thinking about them. Hopefully someday soon I will get to that point! Throughout my life I have used cooking and baking as a means to show support for my family, friends and acquaintances when I noticed a struggle. I’d love to widen the circle.

In this spirit, I have now begun gifting a small bag to each customer with their order. This “gift” is to be given to someone as a randon act of kindness – please help me pay it forward.

Mother’s Day

Slowly easing back into the swing of things while keeping the utmost of safety precautions…
Let me deliver a gift of bakery to that special mother in your life on Sunday, May 10th. I will leave a box on her doorstep with a ribbon and a customized note from you💟
Or, if you prefer, a gift for yourself delivered on your porch with a ribbon and a customized note from me💟

One Year Anniversary

So if you haven’t realized it I’ve kind of been on hiatus…just doesn’t seem right to be posting pictures of baked goods lately. I’ve still gladly been accepting orders just not soliciting. Months ago I was excited for what would have been my big April 1st, 2020 post as this date marks the one year anniversary of my first orders (you know who you are – thank you!!) and I was planning on posting a visually stunning montage of my creations😀 Here’s what I’ll continue to do instead:

Published by Carol Raymonds · March 19 at 8:32 AM ·
If you know someone who is compromised, unable to leave their home, struggling etc….please PM me….I will drop off a gift of baked goods.

And because our situation continues to change daily, I would like to add that this applies to our many, many, many health care heroes as well.

This scenario makes me so happy because if you have read “my story” on my website or FB page you know that my goal was to ultimately provide a pay it forward item with every order received. Just the slightest change here – no order required! I want to help and make a small but hopefully meaningful impact – let’s do this together. Remember – I will leave on your porch or mine❤️❤️❤️